Most agency shortlists are written by the agencies. This one lists the evidence and lets you weigh it.
Match the agency to your deal size first. A sub-$25,000 ACV deal closes in about 90 days, a $100,000 deal takes six to nine months or more (Norwest 2024 benchmarks, via Gradient Works). An agency built for high-volume SMB dialling will not run a nine-month enterprise sequence well. The reverse is also true.
Ask for meeting-to-opportunity conversion, not meeting counts. Ebsta and Pavilion's 2025 GTM Benchmarks, drawn from 655,000 opportunities, put the average B2B win rate at 19%, down from 29% the year before. A hundred meetings that never become opportunities is a cost, not a pipeline.
Get the definition of a qualified meeting in writing. Right title, right company profile, the person knew what the call was about, the person showed up. Any agency that will not put that in the contract is selling activity.
Check who does the work. Ask who writes your copy, who owns your sending domains and what happens to the domains when you leave. Ask for two references from clients six months into the engagement, because month one is never representative.
Read the negative reviews, not the average. Every agency below has a Clutch rating above four except one. The one-star reviews tell you the failure mode. Every agency has one.